The F train to 23rd Street is a loop of muscle memory. I’d done the commute for years as a student, but arriving an hour early on my first day of work felt like a pre-flight check for a mission I wasn't entirely cleared for.
West 24th Street sits in that architectural sweet spot where Chelsea’s grit meets the Flatiron’s ego—pre-war limestone, dim hallways, and the weight of history.
At 7:30 AM, I was peering through the glass of Chermayeff & Geismar & Haviv like a thief sizing up a vault. When Scott let me in and flicked the lights, the studio didn't look like a "creative agency." It looked like a workshop. No beanbags, no espresso bar, no ego-driven "brand activations." Just push-pins, a walk-in stationery cabinet, and a printer positioned at the center like a high altar. It was 1,000 square feet of expensive Manhattan real estate utilized with the spatial economy of a cockpit. And every inch was evaluated with the same rigor as the pixels of a logo. Great design, I realized, is often a mastery of cost-effectiveness.
Later, more people arrived. I sat alone in my cube, busy cluttering my empty iMac screen with random windows to convince my new colleagues that I knew what to do, until the phone rang.
Sagi Haviv’s voice is a blunt instrument—firm, hoarse, and operating at a frequency of permanent urgency. He was the partner I worked with for my internship and he called from a trip with a "special project."
“You know After Effects, right?”
"Uh, yeah," I stuttered.
Of course, I had no fucking idea how to use After Effects. The closest I had ever gotten was making a Flash animation of a blue rectangle morphing into a red circle in a computer class back in third grade.
But on your first day at a firm like this, you don’t say "no." You say "yes," and then you work your ass off until the lie becomes the truth.
The task: Animate every iconic logo the firm had produced since 1957. I had three days. All I had was the "boolean union" confidence to put things together. I didn't need a manual; I needed a deadline.
Sagi returned a few days later in a blue button-down and flip-flops—a power move that defied both logic and age. His energy is a whirlwind; he moves with a slap-slap-slap of rubber on creaky wood, shouting orders about client calls and stock photos.
Across the hall sat Tom Geismar, the serene contrast. Mid-80s, nursing a chilled glass of Ocean Spray cranberry juice. His desk was a Jenga tower of files, a mountain range of logos that would make Mark Twain or Steve Jobs feel at home. The clinking of his ice was the only metronome in the room.
The industry likes to talk about "creative vibes" and "disruption." They imagine designers as latte-sipping aesthetes discussing the latest Bottega bag or that trendy ramen spot in East Village. This is not a place where J. Cole is played in the background. Apparently. CGH was a science lab. We didn't "feel" our way through designs; everyone's got their scientist hat on - the passion, integrity, and persistence to get to the bottom of truth.
I remember on a late Friday night, we were surrounded by hundreds of leopard gecko and red fox prints in the meeting room, acting as anatomists for the acclaimed TV program Animal Planet’s new identity.
Ivan Chermayeff once said in an interview: We have to understand what our clients are, which is not necessarily what they tell us.
On top of that, it took a peculiar kind of courage to defend these investigations. The principals had the audacity to explain to Harvard University that six identical rectangles could represent a century-old publishing house. They stood their ground with Giorgio Armani, returning after an initial rejection to convince him that two serif letters—A and X—were the ultimate statement for his global brand.
In this studio, the goal wasn't to please; it was to find the inevitable.
The most shocking revelation, however, was their relationship with "truth." In a world obsessed with grids and math, these masters relied solely on the naked eye. They would digitize a sketch with perfect metrics, only to throw the metrics away. They spent days tweaking a single kerning, pinching and pulling until the mark looked optically right, even if it was arithmetically wrong. I heard stories of the partners carrying a projector on a trans-Pacific flight just to ensure the client saw the exact right shade of red.
Meanwhile, the rest of the world is rushing toward the other direction, where designers on Fiverr promise a logo for the price of a Frappuccino and AI companies are pitching the lie that "if you can make a taco, you can design a logo." Everyone is looking for a faster tool, yet all we need are people who truly care about what they do.
I left that internship with a few things. I learned After Effects. I knew how to make a logo. I built thirty-odd animations that now live on their site. And I received my first check—fifteen dollars an hour, barely enough for a Brooklyn studio.